Hartford Metro Roofing Contractor Guide
Menu
Request an estimate Call

Taylor Made Roofing

Updated 2026-08-20 · 7,524 reviewed · 200 listed · Scored from 23 Google reviews · How we rank ›

3.3(23) 40 low data composite score See reviews on Google ✓ Google-verified
Roof Replacement

Google-verified23 Google reviews

Taylor Made Roofing
Service
Roof Replacement
Reviews
23

What recent reviews say

Seven years of strong reviews from satisfied customers contrast sharply with a sustained collapse in service. Since around 2017, reviewers report repeated inability to reach the company for warranty work, leaks returning within months, and broken promises to return and fix failed jobs. The shift is dramatic and unrecovered.

Based on limited recent reviews, so treat this as low-confidence.

Praised for
  • honest communication and transparency (older reviews)
  • responsive initially
  • completed jobs efficiently when they did them
Watch-outs
  • unreachable after job completion
  • warranties not honored
  • poor workmanship and leaks recurred
  • no-shows and missed deadlines
  • used aliases to avoid accountability
  • shoddy execution on paid work
missed-deadlinesshoddy-workmanshipleak-recurredpoor-communicationno-show
Think twice if: Recent customers report unreachable phone lines, unanswered warranty claims, and leaks within months of work.

Worth knowing

  • Frank Costellano is the owner named in reviews
  • Company also operates under the name Stark's Roofing according to one review
  • Offered 15-year warranties in earlier years
  • Leaks returned within 3 months on one $6500 job; another customer reported leak recurrence 3 months post-completion
  • One customer waited three weeks for a promised return visit and crew never showed

What reviews say by service

Roof Replacement
Recent complaints of poor workmanship, leaks within months; older reviews praised efficiency and completion

How it compares

  • Rated 3.3 against a 4.69 average across the 172 roof replacement businesses listed here.
  • Has more Google reviews than 63% of the businesses in this directory.

How we scored this

Ranking Method
Star rating 35
Review volume 60
Review recency 0
Review sentiment 40
Profile completeness 50
Verification 0

Rating breakdown

5
13
4
0
3
0
2
0
1
10
Request a quote

Similar roofing contractor nearby

JMS Home Innovations
79

JMS Home Innovations

5.0(18)✓ Google-verified

All 17 reviews awarded five stars, consistently praising Josh and his team for transparent estimates, quality materials, and work that meets or exceeds expectations. Specific strengths include clear communication throughout projects, reasonable pricing compared to larger companies, attention to detail, and thorough cleanup, with multiple reviewers planning to hire them again for future work.

Roof Replacement
View profile
Allied Roofing & Sheet Metal Co Inc
77

Allied Roofing & Sheet Metal Co Inc

4.9(15)✓ Google-verified

Allied Roofing delivers consistent quality across roof replacements with staff who stay responsive and on-site throughout projects. Reviewers praise Adam and the team for explaining work clearly, keeping sites organized, and completing jobs efficiently-with one customer noting the company still serves them seven years after their initial install.

Roof Replacement
View profile
All State Home Improvement
25 low data

All State Home Improvement

No rating yet✓ Google-verified

Review evidence is limited. The business states it is licensed and insured and offers roof replacement, shingle installation, repairs, and storm damage work across Hartford Metro.

Roof Replacement
View profile

Own this business? Get featured

Own or market a business here? Ask about featured placement and advertising on this directory. Your message goes straight to the directory team.

Last updated 2026-08-20