Best roofing contractors in Newington

★★★★★4.7 (427 reviews)score 89/100

With 427 reviews at a 4.7 average, this is the deepest track record on the list, built mostly on window and door work alongside roofing, gutters and baths. Installers Art and Sergei show up on schedule, keep the site clean, and the warranty follow-up gets called out repeatedly by reviewers.

• Largest review base on this list (427) at a 4.7 average
• Named crew (Art, Sergei) with consistently on-time, clean installs
• Active warranty support and post-install site checks
• Broad service menu spanning roofing, windows, doors, gutters and baths

Watch out: Positioned mid-to-premium on price rather than the cheapest bid in town.

Google-verified427 Google reviewssince 1989

Services: roof replacement

★★★★★4.9 (95 reviews)score 89/100

Owner Jeremy and crew (Dave, Matt, Victor, George) take on large exterior projects that mix roofing, siding, trim and windows, with daily photo updates and honest pricing even when they uncover rot or water damage. The 4.9 average across 95 reviews backs up the finish-level detail reviewers keep mentioning.

• 4.9 rating with daily communication and photo updates
• Handles hidden problems like rot or framing damage without surprise charges
• No-pressure, honest estimates led by owner Jeremy
• Clean job sites and meticulous trim and finish work

Google-verified95 Google reviews

Services: roof replacement

★★★★★4.9 (310 reviews)score 89/100

A large sample of 310 reviews at 4.9 makes this one of the most-reviewed crews in the area, known for finishing quickly, leaving sites clean, and fixing minor issues on the spot. Office-side communication on scheduling and billing is the one recurring soft spot reviewers flag.

• 310 reviews at a 4.9 average, among the largest samples on this list
• Crews work fast and leave the site clean
• Competitive pricing reviewers describe as fair
• On-the-spot fixes for minor issues during the job

Watch out: A few reviewers hit scheduling mix-ups and surprise billing or credit-card fees, so confirm terms upfront.

Google-verified310 Google reviews

Services: roof replacement

★★★★★4.9 (161 reviews)score 88/100

Kyle's crew regularly finishes single-day roof jobs faster than quoted, tarping landscaping, texting daily updates, and sending drone photos of the finished roof. The 161-review, 4.9 average is strong, though one customer reported being ghosted before a scheduled appointment, worth weighing against the much larger pattern of praise.

• 161 reviews at 4.9, with jobs often finished same-day
• Transparent about hidden damage (like rotten plywood) and pricing before work starts
• Landscaping protected with tarps during the job
• Daily text updates and drone photos of the completed roof

Watch out: One reported no-show incident and the business isn't BBB-registered, worth a direct conversation before booking.

Google-verified161 Google reviews

Services: roof replacement

★★★★★5 (37 reviews)score 86/100

Every one of Legacy's 37 reviews is five stars, with Leo handling insurance paperwork and adjuster communication directly on roof replacements and multi-layer repairs. Reviewers describe fair pricing against competing bids and bonus touches like free gutter work or old-structure removal thrown in.

• Perfect 5.0 average, on a smaller sample of 37 reviews
• Leo manages insurance claims and adjuster communication directly
• Fair, competitor-checked pricing with no surprise overcharges
• Extras like gutter work or removals added at no charge

Google-verified37 Google reviews

Services: roof replacement

★★★★★5 (38 reviews)score 86/100

Jay's team turns most roof replacements around in a single day and leaves the site spotless, backed by a perfect 5.0 across 38 reviews. Pricing is repeatedly called out as undercutting competitors, with Jay personally involved in estimates.

• Perfect 5.0 average across 38 reviews
• Most roof replacements completed in one day
• Owner Jay personally handles estimates and stays responsive
• Thorough cleanup with nothing left behind on site

Google-verified38 Google reviews

Services: roof replacement

★★★★★5 (2 reviews)score 68/100

This HIC-licensed contractor reportedly has 35-plus years in business and covers replacements, repairs, inspections and structural work, but online reviews are limited to just two so far. Both are five-star and mention competitive pricing and careful attention, a promising early signal rather than a proven volume track record.

• HIC-licensed with 35+ years reportedly in operation
• Covers replacements, repairs, inspections and structural work

Watch out: Only two reviews on record, so get references before committing to a larger job.

Google-verified2 Google reviews35+ years

Services: roof replacement

★★★★★5 (3 reviews)score 65/100

Operating since 1979, this crew has institutional and commercial roofing experience, including work cited at Cornell University, and reviewers describe being treated like long-term clients rather than one-off jobs. Only three reviews are on record so far, all five stars.

• In business since 1979 with institutional-scale project history
• Experience with commercial and metal roofing systems

Watch out: Review volume is thin (3 reviews), so this is more of a reputational bet than a data-backed one.

Google-verified3 Google reviewssince 1979

Services: roof replacement

★★★★★5 (6 reviews)score 62/100

All six reviews on file are five stars, with reviewers pointing to fair pricing, quick quote turnaround, and precise shingle matching on repairs and full replacements. It's a small sample and the review activity looks dated, so treat it as a lead worth a fresh quote rather than a proven volume performer.

• Six-for-six five-star reviews
• Reviewers highlight precise shingle matching

Watch out: Review activity appears dated, so confirm current availability and pricing directly.

6 Google reviewsover 20 years

Services: roof replacement

score 25/100

Pelletier lists roofing, siding, windows, doors and remodeling services for the Newington area, but there is no review data yet to confirm real-world performance. Worth a call for another bid to compare, just go in knowing there's no track record here to check against.

• Service menu covers roofing, siding, windows, doors and remodeling

Watch out: No review data is available, so there's nothing yet to verify quality or reliability.

Services: roof replacement

score 21/100

BlueTeam's site lists roof replacement alongside broader damage restoration and construction services, but there's no review evidence yet and no confirmation of how much of their local work is roofing-specific. Treat it as an option to vet directly with your own questions rather than one with a demonstrated track record.

• Roof replacement listed alongside broader restoration and construction services

Watch out: No reviews on file and no confirmed Newington-area roofing track record, so verify licensing and experience directly.

Google-verified

Services: roof replacement