Best roofing contractors in Newington

★★★★★4.9 (100 reviews)score 90/100

Sensible Home Products earns the top composite score on the strength of 100 reviews averaging 4.9, with reviewers describing owner Jeremy as hands-on through every stage of siding, window, gutter, deck, and masonry jobs. The pattern across reviews is unusually consistent: transparent options when problems like rot or water damage turn up, and named crew members singled out for careful trim work and daily cleanup.

• Owner Jeremy calls with progress photos and shows up during the work
• Crew members Victor, Alec, Vladimir and Dave praised by name for precision trim and cleanup
• Honest about material upgrades rather than cutting scope to save money
• Handles unexpected structural issues (rot, water damage) transparently

Watch out: Pricing reflects premium materials like fiberglass siding and Trex decking, so this isn't the cheapest option.

Google-verified100 Google reviews

Services: roof replacement

★★★★★4.7 (428 reviews)score 89/100

With 428 reviews at 4.7 stars, Peoples Home Remodeling has the largest track record on this list, and installation crews led by named techs Art and Sergei consistently get credit for skilled, courteous work. A project manager inspects jobs at day's end, and one reviewer had a defective part replaced overnight under warranty.

• Named technicians Art and Sergei praised repeatedly for skill and courtesy
• Project manager inspects work the same day
• Overnight warranty replacement on defective parts
• Job sites left clean after work

Watch out: One reviewer flagged pricing as higher than some competitors, though attributed to reliability.

Google-verified428 Google reviewssince 1989

Services: roof replacement

★★★★★4.9 (163 reviews)score 89/100

KM&M Roofing has 163 reviews at 4.9 stars and a strong reputation for finishing residential replacements in a single day, with owner Kyle Murgo personally handling transparent quotes and progress updates. The crew, including foreman Edgar, gets specific praise for protecting landscaping and leaving spotless job sites even on complex jobs involving plywood replacement or storm damage.

• Most roof replacements completed in one day
• Owner Kyle available directly for quotes and updates
• Crew protects landscaping and cleans up thoroughly
• Handles complex issues like water damage and storm tarping

Watch out: One customer reported a no-show appointment and no final walk-through years ago, an isolated complaint against 163 reviews.

Google-verified163 Google reviews

Services: roof replacement

★★★★★4.9 (320 reviews)score 88/100

Premier Gutter Services has amassed 320 reviews at 4.9 stars, with most visits described as fast, professional, and left clean by polite crews. It's the strongest gutter-focused specialist on this list, though a share of reviewers report office-side friction around scheduling and billing.

• Prompt, courteous crews on most jobs
• Clean site left after installation
• Knowledgeable technicians who assess gutter condition honestly
• High review volume backing up consistent ratings

Watch out: Some reviewers cite scheduling confusion and price changes between quote and final invoice.

Google-verified320 Google reviews

Services: roof replacement

★★★★★5 (38 reviews)score 86/100

Modern Roofing holds a perfect 5.0 across 38 reviews, with owner Jay handling estimates personally and crews finishing most roof replacements in a single day at prices reviewers describe as undercutting competitors. The review count is smaller than the top names here, but the sentiment is uniformly positive on speed, cleanup, and honesty.

• Perfect 5.0 rating across all reviews
• One-day turnaround on most roof replacements
• Owner Jay personally involved in estimates
• Pricing reviewers describe as fair and competitive

Watch out: Fewer reviews (38) than the top-ranked contractors, so the track record is shorter.

Google-verified38 Google reviews

Services: roof replacement

★★★★★5 (2 reviews)score 68/100

Trusted Roofing brings over 35 years in the trade and HIC licensing, covering replacements, repairs, inspections, and structural work. Both available reviews describe professional, detail-oriented crews at competitive prices, but with only two reviews on record this is a low-confidence pick worth verifying directly.

• 35+ years of operating history
• HIC-licensed contractor

Watch out: Only two reviews are on record, so there isn't much data to judge consistency.

Google-verified2 Google reviews35+ years

Services: roof replacement

★★★★★5 (3 reviews)score 64/100

New Britain Roofing Co has been operating since 1979 and counts institutional work, including a Cornell University project, among its history. All three available reviews are five stars and describe a team that treats customers personally, but the review sample is small enough to treat this as an early-signal pick rather than a proven volume leader.

• Operating since 1979 with institutional-scale project experience
• Handles commercial and metal roofing systems

Watch out: Only three reviews are available, so the sample is thin relative to others on this list.

Google-verified3 Google reviewssince 1979

Services: roof replacement

★★★★★5 (5 reviews)score 62/100

Roofing Contractor of Newington claims over 20 years serving Newington and Hartford County, and its five available reviews are all five stars, citing fair pricing, quick response, and precise shingle matching on replacement jobs. It's a promising local option, though the review count is still small enough to weigh carefully.

• Fair pricing noted across all reviews
• Quick response time

Watch out: Based on only five reviews, so treat the rating as an early indicator rather than a large sample.

5 Google reviewsover 20 years

Services: roof replacement

score 25/100

Pelletier Roofing & Siding lists roofing, siding, windows, doors, and remodeling for the Newington area, but there's no review data available yet to confirm how the work holds up in practice. Worth a direct conversation if the service mix fits your project, but go in knowing this is unverified by customer feedback.

• Covers roofing, siding, windows, doors and remodeling in one shop
• Based locally in Newington, CT

Watch out: No customer reviews are available, so there's no track record to evaluate yet.

Services: roof replacement

score 21/100

BlueTeam lists roof replacement alongside a broader slate of damage restoration and construction services, but there's no review history and its site doesn't confirm Hartford-area coverage specifically. It sits at the bottom of this list mainly for lack of verifiable customer feedback rather than any negative signal.

• Offers roof replacement as part of a wider restoration and construction service line

Watch out: No reviews are on record, and Hartford-area service availability isn't clearly confirmed.

Google-verified

Services: roof replacement