Best roofing contractors in Southington

★★★★★4.8 (317 reviews)score 91/100

J.C. Tonnotti posts the highest composite score on this list, backed by 317 reviews at a 4.8 average, which is a lot of recent, consistent feedback to earn that spot. Reviewers describe same-day completions on windows, doors, roofing, siding, and gutters, with owner Joe personally involved in quality checks throughout.

• Crew arrives on time and finishes most jobs same day
• Thorough cleanup after every job
• Clear communication from quote through handoff
• Owner personally oversees quality

Google-verified317 Google reviewssince 1979

Services: roof replacement

★★★★★5 (50 reviews)score 88/100

First Choice Roofing pairs a perfect 5.0 rating across 50 reviews with a reputation for showing up fast when a roof is actively leaking. Owner Vinny answers his own phone, inspects damage in person, and reviewers describe jobs wrapping up in one to two days even when more time was quoted.

• Owner Vinny personally answers calls and visits sites
• Jobs often finish faster than the original timeline
• Competitive, family-business pricing
• Site left immaculate after work

Google-verified50 Google reviews

Services: roof replacement

★★★★★5 (203 reviews)score 86/100

Epic Exteriors has the deepest review base here, 203 reviews at a near-perfect 5.0, and staff like Kyle, Tyler, and Casey are named repeatedly for smooth scheduling and full insurance claim handling. Sentiment reads mixed rather than purely positive because one review described a ceiling damage incident that took several attempts to resolve properly.

• High review volume with consistently high ratings
• On-site project manager for the duration of the job
• Insurance paperwork handled for you
• Detailed cleanup, including magnet nail sweeps

Watch out: One reviewer described accidental ceiling damage that needed multiple visits to fix, and some noted pushy sales follow-up after signing.

Google-verified203 Google reviews

Services: roof replacement

★★★★★5 (22 reviews)score 84/100

City Roofing earns a perfect 5.0 across 22 reviews, with owner Matt inspecting jobs himself and recommending a repair instead of a full replacement when that's genuinely all that's needed. With 22 reviews behind it, this is a solid track record, though smaller than the top names on this list.

• Owner Matt handles estimates and inspections personally
• Will recommend repair over replacement when appropriate
• Same-day or next-day callbacks
• Crews clean up thoroughly and finish on schedule

Google-verified22 Google reviewssince 1958

Services: roof replacement

★★★★★5 (22 reviews)score 84/100

Premier One holds a perfect 5.0 across 22 reviews, with a named crew (Luis, Rafael, Joseline, Josayra) that walks homeowners through the plan before starting and follows up after the job. Several reviews mention the team helping upgrade an approved repair into a full insurance-covered replacement.

• All reviews are five-star
• Staff help push insurance approvals toward full replacement
• Roofs often completed in a single day
• Post-job inspection and follow-up as standard practice

Google-verified22 Google reviewsover 10 years

Services: roof replacement

★★★★★4.5 (20 reviews)score 79/100

Apple Valley scores well with 20 reviews at a 4.5 average, and homeowners consistently point to George Schmidt being present from quote through completion. It's a smaller review base than the top of this list, so treat it as a solid, if less extensively tested, option.

• Owner George present throughout the project
• Roof jobs often completed same day
• Transparent pricing and options up front
• Thorough site cleanup after work

Google-verified20 Google reviews

Services: roof replacement

★★★★★5 (11 reviews)score 76/100

SRW has a perfect 5.0 rating, but on only 11 reviews, so treat this as a promising, lightly-reviewed option rather than a proven high-volume track record. What's there is uniformly positive: owner Joe leads jobs personally, responds to emergencies within hours, and manages insurance claims start to finish.

• Owner Joe personally handles the work
• Full insurance claim support from filing to completion
• Emergency response within hours
• Fair pricing with thorough cleanup

Google-verified11 Google reviews

Services: roof replacement

★★★★☆4.4 (13 reviews)score 55/100

Northeast Roofing has a 4.4 average across 13 reviews and a track record of same-day service from owner Ron, including warranty work honored years after installation. The composite score is pulled down by mixed sentiment and stale recency data, so weigh the two early complaints against the broader praise before deciding.

• Owner Ron personally oversees jobs
• Same-day or next-day turnaround on most calls
• Warranty honored years after the original install
• Fair pricing

Watch out: Two earlier reviews mention a leak recurring after install and slow callback response.

13 Google reviews

Services: roof replacement

score 25/100

This business currently has no reviews on record, so there isn't yet a reliable sentiment or track record to evaluate against the other contractors on this list. It's included here for completeness, but homeowners should ask for references directly given the lack of review history.

Watch out: No reviews available yet, so there is no track record to verify quality or reliability.

Services: roof replacement