Hartford Metro Roofing Contractor Guide
Menu

Roof Replacement in Newington

Roof Replacement in Hartford Metro

Roof replacement means stripping the existing roofing material down to the deck (or in some cases overlaying it, though tear-off is usually the better long-term choice), repairing any damaged sheathing, installing new underlayment and flashing, and laying down new shingles, metal panels, or another roofing system. It's a bigger job than a repair or a patch: it typically takes anywhere from one to three days for an average house, involves a full crew, and requires permits and inspection in most towns, Newington included. Because it's expensive and disruptive if done poorly, it's one of the home projects where picking the right contractor matters more than shaving a few hundred dollars off the estimate.

We track 11 roof replacement businesses serving Newington. When you're comparing them, look past the sales pitch and check for a few concrete things: a physical local address and history in the area, manufacturer certifications (which usually extend the material warranty beyond the standard one), a written estimate that breaks out tear-off, materials, flashing, ventilation, and disposal separately, and proof of liability insurance and workers' comp. Ask how they handle unexpected deck damage found after tear-off, since that's the most common source of surprise costs.

Our ranked guide to roofing contractors in Newington scores businesses on factors like review consistency, responsiveness, and how they handle complaints, not just star averages. Details on how we weigh those factors are on our methodology page.

Find roof replacement in Newington for your project

Free, no obligation. Describe your roof project and we'll connect you with qualified contractors.

Compare quotes

All roof replacement in Newington, ranked by score and relevance

11 businesses, scored on recent reviews. The order weighs each business's overall score by how much of its reviewed work is roof replacement, so a lower-scored specialist can rank above a higher-scored generalist.

Peoples Home Remodeling
#1
89

Peoples Home Remodeling

4.7(427)✓ Google-verifiedPublishes prices

Art, Sergei, and the installation crew consistently arrive on schedule, complete work professionally, and leave no mess behind. Homeowners praise the knowledgeable sales process, attentive project management, and warranty support, though the company is positioned as mid-to-premium rather than budget. Windows and door replacements dominate the reviews. Custom work like tub-to-shower conversions and glass repairs earn consistent five-star marks. Customers value the follow-up-early replacement of defective parts, email guidance on care, and a site check after the final day.

Roof Replacement
Sensible Home Products LLC
#2
89

Sensible Home Products LLC

4.9(95)✓ Google-verified

Jeremy and his crew consistently deliver large exterior projects with precision and genuine care. Reviewers experience transparent communication from estimate through project completion, often with daily check-ins and photo updates. The team handles unexpected issues (rot, water damage, framing problems) without complaint or surprise charges, explains options honestly, and cleans thoroughly each day. Staff including Jeremy, Dave, Matt, Victor, and George treat homes and customers as priorities. Trim work, siding, windows, decks, and roof repairs earn repeated praise for both quality and aesthetic touch.

Roof Replacement
Premier Gutter Services LLC
#3
89

Premier Gutter Services LLC

4.9(310)✓ Google-verified

Premier Gutter Services earns strong marks for quality work and fair prices. Crews finish fast, leave sites clean, and address minor issues on the spot. That said, office communication about appointment timing and billing terms needs work-one reviewer navigated three price changes and surprise scheduling/credit-card fees without upfront notice.

Roof Replacement
KM&M Roofing LLC
#4
88

KM&M Roofing LLC

4.9(161)✓ Google-verifiedPublishes prices

Kyle and his crew arrive on time, work long hours in tough conditions, and finish single-day jobs faster than quoted. They tarp plants, send progress photos, clean everything before leaving, and communicate daily via text. One customer reported being ghosted before an appointment he said Kyle scheduled, citing seven complaints against the business and a no-show pattern online; however, 160 other reviews describe consistent, trustworthy service. Material choices (asphalt, metal, rubber EPDM) and hidden damage discoveries (rotten plywood requiring replacement) are handled transparently with full explanations. A foreman leads the crew on-site. Kyle answers questions without pressure and sends drone photos of completed work. Pricing consistently draws praise as reasonable given the quality and speed.

Roof Replacement
Legacy Built Renovations
#5
86

Legacy Built Renovations

5.0(37)✓ Google-verified

Leo and his crew show up on time and finish fast without cutting corners. Reviewers consistently praise fair pricing, clear communication throughout the job, and a property left spotless. They handle insurance paperwork, send progress photos, and go beyond the scope (removing old structures, adding free upgrades). The whole experience feels easy and honest. Their roof replacements and multi-layer repairs are backed by real craftsmanship. Leo responds quickly, works with homeowners and adjusters directly, and delivers exactly what he quotes. No surprises, no overcharging, and reviewers feel confident enough to hire them again.

Roof Replacement

Find roof replacement in Newington for your project

Free, no obligation. Describe your roof project and we'll connect you with qualified contractors.

Compare quotes
Modern Roofing
#6
86

Modern Roofing

5.0(38)✓ Google-verified

Jay and his team deliver roof replacements in one day with no trace left behind. Reviewers consistently praise the owner's responsiveness, honest estimates, and crew professionalism, with pricing that undercuts competitors.

Roof Replacement
Trusted Roofing, LLC
#7
68 low data

Trusted Roofing, LLC

5.0(2)✓ Google-verified

Both reviewers praised Trusted Roofing for professional work, competitive pricing, and careful attention. Limited review sample, but early signs suggest solid execution on roof and structural projects.

Roof Replacement
New Britain Roofing Co Inc
#8
65 low data

New Britain Roofing Co Inc

5.0(3)✓ Google-verified

New Britain Roofing has completed institutional projects like Cornell University work and built a reputation for treating customers like friends. With all five-star reviews, the team shows strong reliability and craftsmanship across commercial and metal roofing systems.

Roof Replacement
Roofing Contractor of Newington
#9
62 low data

Roofing Contractor of Newington

5.0(6)

All six reviews are five-star; customers praise fair pricing, quick responses, and precise shingle matching. Work spans full replacements, skylight repairs, and gutter fixes with no complaints recorded.

Roof Replacement
Pelletier Roofing & Siding
#10
25 low data

Pelletier Roofing & Siding

No rating yet

Review data for this business is not available. Their website lists roofing, siding, windows, doors, and remodeling services in Newington, CT.

Roof Replacement
B
#11
21 low data

BlueTeam

No rating yet✓ Google-verified

Review evidence is limited. The business's website lists roof replacement among a broad range of damage restoration and construction services, though it does not specify Hartford-area availability or customer feedback on roofing work.

Roof Replacement

Get quotes from our featured partners

How many quotes do you want?

By submitting, you agree that your enquiry is shared with providers relevant to your request.

Your enquiries may be shared with partner providers to complete the work, and we may earn a referral fee. Our rankings are based on our published scoring method only and are never affected by referral fees.

Last updated 2026-08-20