Hartford Metro Roofing Contractor Guide
Menu

Roof Replacement in Newington

Roof Replacement in Hartford Metro

Roof replacement means stripping the existing roofing material down to the deck (or in some cases overlaying it, though tear-off is usually the better long-term choice), repairing any damaged sheathing, installing new underlayment and flashing, and laying down new shingles, metal panels, or another roofing system. It's a bigger job than a repair or a patch: it typically takes anywhere from one to three days for an average house, involves a full crew, and requires permits and inspection in most towns, Newington included. Because it's expensive and disruptive if done poorly, it's one of the home projects where picking the right contractor matters more than shaving a few hundred dollars off the estimate.

We track 11 roof replacement businesses serving Newington. When you're comparing them, look past the sales pitch and check for a few concrete things: a physical local address and history in the area, manufacturer certifications (which usually extend the material warranty beyond the standard one), a written estimate that breaks out tear-off, materials, flashing, ventilation, and disposal separately, and proof of liability insurance and workers' comp. Ask how they handle unexpected deck damage found after tear-off, since that's the most common source of surprise costs.

Our ranked guide to roofing contractors in Newington scores businesses on factors like review consistency, responsiveness, and how they handle complaints, not just star averages. Details on how we weigh those factors are on our methodology page.

Find roof replacement in Newington for your project

Free, no obligation. Describe your roof project and we'll connect you with qualified contractors.

Compare quotes

All roof replacement in Newington, ranked by score and relevance

10 businesses, scored on recent reviews. The order weighs each business's overall score by how much of its reviewed work is roof replacement, so a lower-scored specialist can rank above a higher-scored generalist.

Sensible Home Products LLC
#1
90

Sensible Home Products LLC

4.9(100)✓ Google-verified

Homeowners consistently encounter a responsive owner (Jeremy) who listens, explains options honestly, and mobilizes a crew that finishes with care and precision. Work includes siding, windows, gutters, decks, and masonry; specific crew members Victor, Alec, Vladimir, and Dave earn named praise for detailed trim work, daily cleanup, and treating homes as their own during projects often lasting weeks. Every review highlights professionalism and communication. Jeremy calls with progress photos, shows up during work, and handles unexpected findings (rot, water damage, structural issues) by walking the homeowner through options transparently. Pricing reflects higher-quality materials (premium fiberglass siding, Trex decks) rather than budget cuts; multiple reviewers note Jeremy negotiates on scope rather than corners.

Roof Replacement
Peoples Home Remodeling
#2
89

Peoples Home Remodeling

4.7(428)✓ Google-verifiedPublishes prices

Installation teams arrive on schedule and execute window and door work with precision. Staff communicate clearly throughout, tidy up after themselves, and troubleshoot issues proactively. One reviewer noted pricing is higher than some competitors but reflects quality and reliability. Art and Sergei are named repeatedly for handling jobs skillfully and courteously. The company sends project managers to inspect work at day's end. One reviewer received a defective shower part replaced overnight. Warranty repairs are handled without hassle.

Roof Replacement
KM&M Roofing LLC
#3
89

KM&M Roofing LLC

4.9(163)✓ Google-verifiedPublishes prices

Most customers praise KM&M for fast, professional roof replacements completed on schedule, often in a single day. Kyle Murgo and his crew are noted for fair pricing, transparent communication with progress photos, meticulous cleanup, and protective measures around the property. One customer reported a no-call no-show appointment years ago and noted the owner did not conduct a final walk-through, though this is isolated in 163 reviews. The business handles complex projects well, including unexpected plywood replacement and storm-damage tarping. They serve residential replacements across Connecticut and offer financing starting at $100/month. Crew members like foreman Edgar are named by satisfied customers.

Roof Replacement
Premier Gutter Services LLC
#4
88

Premier Gutter Services LLC

4.9(320)✓ Google-verified

Most visits result in fast, professional work with polite crews who leave the site clean. Job quality and pricing are generally solid, but office scheduling, communication delays, and incremental billing changes frustrate some customers.

Roof Replacement
Modern Roofing
#5
86

Modern Roofing

5.0(38)✓ Google-verified

Jay and his team deliver roof replacements in one day with no trace left behind. Reviewers consistently praise the owner's responsiveness, honest estimates, and crew professionalism, with pricing that undercuts competitors.

Roof Replacement

Find roof replacement in Newington for your project

Free, no obligation. Describe your roof project and we'll connect you with qualified contractors.

Compare quotes
Trusted Roofing, LLC
#6
68 low data

Trusted Roofing, LLC

5.0(2)✓ Google-verified

Both reviewers praised Trusted Roofing for professional work, competitive pricing, and careful attention. Limited review sample, but early signs suggest solid execution on roof and structural projects.

Roof Replacement
New Britain Roofing Co Inc
#7
64 low data

New Britain Roofing Co Inc

5.0(3)✓ Google-verified

New Britain Roofing has completed institutional projects like Cornell University work and built a reputation for treating customers like friends. With all five-star reviews, the team shows strong reliability and craftsmanship across commercial and metal roofing systems.

Roof Replacement
Roofing Contractor of Newington
#8
62 low data

Roofing Contractor of Newington

5.0(5)

All five Google reviews rate this Newington contractor at five stars. Reviewers highlight fair pricing, rapid responses, and precise craftsmanship in roof replacement and shingle work. The business claims over 20 years in operation and serves Newington, Hartford County, and the broader Connecticut area.

Roof Replacement
Pelletier Roofing & Siding
#9
25 low data

Pelletier Roofing & Siding

No rating yet

Review data for this business is not available. Their website lists roofing, siding, windows, doors, and remodeling services in Newington, CT.

Roof Replacement
B
#10
21 low data

BlueTeam

No rating yet✓ Google-verified

Review evidence is limited. The business's website lists roof replacement among a broad range of damage restoration and construction services, though it does not specify Hartford-area availability or customer feedback on roofing work.

Roof Replacement

Get quotes from our featured partners

How many quotes do you want?

By submitting, you agree that your enquiry is shared with providers relevant to your request.

Enquiries submitted through our contact forms may be shared with partner providers who can do the work, and we may receive a referral fee. Our rankings and scores are based on our published method and are not influenced by referral fees.

Last updated 2026-09-20