Hartford Metro Roofing Contractor Guide
Menu

Roof Replacement in Southington

Roof Replacement in Hartford Metro

Roof replacement in Southington

A roof replacement means stripping the existing shingles (or other roofing material) down to the deck, repairing any rotten or water-damaged sheathing, installing new underlayment and flashing, and laying a new roof system on top. It's a bigger job than a repair or a re-roof over existing layers, and it's usually the right call once a roof is near the end of its life, has widespread leaks, or has sustained damage that spot repairs can't fix. In Southington, that typically means asphalt shingle roofs dealing with New England winters: ice damming, freeze-thaw cycles, and wind-driven rain that finds any weak spot in flashing or underlayment.

Nine roofing contractors serve the area for this kind of work, and the range in price, materials, and workmanship is real. When you're comparing quotes, look past the bottom-line number and check what's actually included: tear-off and disposal, new plywood where needed, ice-and-water shield along eaves and valleys, ventilation upgrades, and flashing around chimneys and skylights. Ask about manufacturer certifications, since some shingle warranties only apply if the installer is certified to install them. Licensing, insurance, and a written contract with a clear scope of work matter just as much as the estimate itself.

Our ranked guide to Southington roofing contractors scores companies on factors like license standing, review history, and responsiveness, so you can shortlist before you start collecting quotes. Details on how we weigh those factors are on our methodology page.

Find roof replacement in Southington for your project

Free, no obligation. Describe your roof project and we'll connect you with qualified contractors.

Compare quotes

All roof replacement in Southington, ranked by score and relevance

9 businesses, scored on recent reviews. The order weighs each business's overall score by how much of its reviewed work is roof replacement, so a lower-scored specialist can rank above a higher-scored generalist.

J.C. Tonnotti Window Company
#1
91

J.C. Tonnotti Window Company

4.8(317)✓ Google-verified

Every recent review praises J.C. Tonnotti's timeliness, crew professionalism, and cleanup standards. Homeowners consistently highlight skilled installation of custom and standard windows, transparent communication from sales through handoff, and the owner Joe's personal involvement in quality oversight. Crews named include Paul, Chris, Luke, Jeremiah, Mike, and Ava. The company handles windows (double-hung, casement, bay, custom atrium), doors, roofing, siding, and gutters. Installation typically completes in one day. Reviewers report feeling confident before work begins and satisfied with results afterward.

Roof Replacement
First Choice Roofing
#2
88

First Choice Roofing

5.0(50)✓ Google-verified

Vinny and his crew turn roof emergencies into smooth experiences. From a leaking roof right before a rainstorm to storm damage repairs completed between sunrise and mid-morning, reviewers consistently report same-day or next-morning response, honest assessment of options, and work that finishes in one or two days instead of the promised timeframe. The owner answers the phone himself, visits sites promptly to inspect damage, and his team leaves properties immaculate. Shingles are matched precisely, gutters and leaf guards are installed without pressure, and competitive pricing combined with family-business values sets them apart from larger roofing corporations. Even minor hiccups get immediate attention: when one roof had an issue post-install, Vinny returned the same day to fix it completely. This is a team that takes pride in workmanship, shows up when they say they will, and treats both small storm damage and full replacements with the same professionalism.

Roof Replacement
Epic Exteriors LLC
#3
86

Epic Exteriors LLC

5.0(203)✓ Google-verified

Epic Exteriors earns consistent five-star reviews for quick roof replacements, reliable crew performance, and strong insurance claim support. Named staff like Kyle, Tyler, and Casey routinely stay in touch, handle scheduling around customer needs, and finish jobs in a day or two with thorough cleanup. One recent three-star review broke the pattern: a worker accidentally created ceiling damage during installation, and while the company eventually fixed it properly, the repair took multiple attempts and required customer persistence. Post-contract communication also faltered when a sales rep texted assumptions about competitor choices before the customer could respond. The company's strength lies in execution and crew coordination. Project managers stay on-site, catch debris with magnets after completion, and manage insurance paperwork. Weakness emerged in handling accident follow-up and sales pressure afterward, suggesting quality control remains strong but customer service recovery needs work when things go wrong.

Roof Replacement
City Roofing & Siding Inc.
#4
84

City Roofing & Siding Inc.

5.0(22)✓ Google-verified

City Roofing earns consistent five-star reviews for owner Matt's direct involvement and honest approach. He inspects jobs himself, calls back the same day, and opts for repairs when replacements aren't needed, charging fairly and leaving sites spotless. Crews arrive on time and finish efficiently, often completing work ahead of schedule.

Roof Replacement
Premier One Roofing & Siding LLC
#5
84

Premier One Roofing & Siding LLC

5.0(22)✓ Google-verified

All 22 reviews are five-star. Customers highlight how Luis, Rafael, Joseline, and Josayra explain work upfront, finish roofs quickly, and leave homes spotless. Staff help navigate insurance claims and secure full replacements where repairs were initially approved. Post-job inspections and follow-ups are mentioned as standard practice.

Roof Replacement

Find roof replacement in Southington for your project

Free, no obligation. Describe your roof project and we'll connect you with qualified contractors.

Compare quotes
Apple Valley Home Improvement LLC
#6
79

Apple Valley Home Improvement LLC

4.5(20)✓ Google-verified

George Schmidt and his crew consistently deliver roof replacements on schedule and leave properties clean. Homeowners praise transparent pricing, professional subcontractors, and George's presence throughout the project, from quote to completion.

Roof Replacement
SRW LLC - Specialized Restoration Work
#7
76 low data

SRW LLC - Specialized Restoration Work

5.0(11)✓ Google-verified

Every review is five stars. Joe leads the work personally, handles insurance claims from start to finish, and shows up for emergency calls within hours. Homeowners consistently praise fair pricing, quality craftsmanship, and cleanup that exceeds expectations. No complaints appear in the available reviews.

Roof Replacement
NR
#8
55 low data

Northeast Roofing,LLC

4.4(13)

Most jobs finish fast and clean, with owner Ron known for same-day service and honoring work years later. Two early complaints about post-install leaks and unresponsive callbacks stand apart from the broader pattern of praise.

Roof Replacement

Get quotes from our featured partners

How many quotes do you want?

By submitting, you agree that your enquiry is shared with providers relevant to your request.

Your enquiries may be shared with partner providers to complete the work, and we may earn a referral fee. Our rankings are based on our published scoring method only and are never affected by referral fees.

Common questions about roof replacement

How much does a roof replacement cost in Southington?
Most asphalt shingle roof replacements on a typical single-family home run into the five-figure range, with cost driven by roof size, pitch, number of layers being removed, decking repairs, and shingle grade. Steeper or more complex roofs (multiple valleys, dormers, chimneys) cost more due to labor time. Get itemized quotes from at least two or three local contractors so you're comparing the same scope of work.
How often does a roof actually need to be replaced?
A well-installed asphalt shingle roof generally lasts 20 to 25 years, though that depends on ventilation, installation quality, and how much sun and weather exposure the roof gets. Roofs in shaded, north-facing areas often outlast south-facing slopes. Regular inspections after major storms can catch damage early and stretch the life of the roof.
What should I expect during the replacement process?
Expect a crew on-site for one to three days depending on roof size and weather. They'll tear off old shingles, inspect and replace damaged decking, install new underlayment and flashing, then lay new shingles. There will be noise, debris in the yard (a dumpster or trailer is normal), and some dust inside the house. A reputable contractor will do a final walkthrough and magnetic sweep for nails before leaving.
How can I judge the quality of a roofing contractor before hiring?
Check that they carry a current license and liability insurance, ask for local references or recent job addresses you can drive by, and see if they're certified installers for the shingle brand they're proposing (this affects warranty coverage). A contractor who does a thorough on-roof inspection before quoting, rather than pricing from a satellite photo alone, is usually a good sign.

Last updated 2026-08-20